Home » Blog » Heating » Gas Heater vs. Electric Heater

Gas Heater vs. Electric Heater

Gas Heater vs. Electric Heater

At Lex Air Conditioning and Heating, we understand the importance (and challenges) of choosing the right heating system for your Carrollton home or business. In this guide, we jump into the age-old debate of gas heaters versus electric heaters. Whether seeking energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, or environmental considerations, our heating experts can help you choose the best heater to suit your needs. 

To schedule a heating consultation with one of our Carrollton heating pros, call Lex Air at (972) 217-8955 or contact us online today. 

Which is Better: a Gas or Electric Heater? 

Choosing between a gas heater or an electric heater depends on many factors. Understanding how the heating systems differ is important as they vary in many areas, including heating styles, efficiency, costs, and more. In the section below, we’ll provide a brief overview of gas heating systems and electric heating systems. While both are great options to heat your Carrollton home or business, deciding which is better is ultimately up to you.  

Gas Heating Systems in Carrollton

Overview of Gas Heaters

Gas heaters are popular for heating residential and commercial spaces due to their efficiency and reliability. These heaters burn natural gas or propane in a combustion chamber to produce heat. Natural gas heaters are connected to a gas line, providing a continuous fuel supply, while propane heaters rely on refillable tanks. 

Popular types of gas heaters include forced-air furnaces, which distribute warm air through ducts, and radiant heaters, which emit heat in a specific direction, often through infrared technology. Gas heaters are known for their quick and effective heating capabilities, making them a preferred choice in regions with harsh winters or large areas requiring substantial warmth.

Gas Heaters Pros and Cons

There are several advantages to choosing a gas furnace, including its high efficiency and powerful heating capabilities. They are often more cost-effective to run than electric heaters in areas with access to affordable natural gas or propane. 

It’s important to consider the installation cost, as setting up a gas heater may involve additional expenses, especially if you need to install gas lines or propane tanks. Safety concerns are another consideration, as gas heat emits carbon monoxide and requires proper ventilation and maintenance to ensure safe operation. 

Electric Heating Systems in Carrollton

Overview of Electric Heaters

Electric furnaces are also widely used for heating both residential and commercial spaces. These heaters pass an electric current through a resistive element, such as a coil or ceramic plate, which generates heat. 

Convection heaters warm the air around them, creating circulation and evenly distributing warmth throughout a room. On the other hand, infrared heaters emit infrared radiation that directly heats objects and people in their path, providing rapid and targeted warmth. 

Electric Heaters Pros and Cons

Electric heaters are considered safer than gas furnaces because they do not produce carbon monoxide or involve open flames. Electric heaters are also available in various sizes and types, making them versatile for various heating needs. 

However, they can be less cost-effective to operate compared to gas heaters in regions with high electricity costs, which may impact long-term running expenses. Electric heaters may struggle to heat larger spaces efficiently, as their heating capacity is typically lower than that of gas heaters, requiring careful consideration of room size and insulation.

Comparing Gas vs. Electric Heaters

The next section provides a comprehensive comparison between gas and electric heaters. We will examine critical factors, including efficiency, cost-effectiveness, environmental impact, safety considerations, and heating capacity. By weighing the pros and cons of gas and electric heaters, you’ll better understand which option is best for your specific heating requirements and preferences. 


One way an electric furnace differs from a gas one is how much it costs to operate. Gas heaters are generally more energy-efficient, providing more heat for each unit of energy consumed. This makes them more cost-effective in areas where natural gas is reasonably priced. Electric heating costs are higher compared to gas since electricity tends to be more expensive per unit of energy than natural gas. 

Installation and Maintenance

Installation and maintenance requirements can significantly differ between electric and gas heaters. Gas heaters often require more intricate installation due to the need for gas lines, proper ventilation, and additional safety measures to prevent carbon monoxide leaks. Regular maintenance and gas leak checks are crucial for safety. 

Electric heaters are generally easier to install, requiring only a standard electrical outlet. Maintenance for electric heaters is usually minimal, primarily involving periodic cleaning and ensuring the electrical components are in good condition.

Environmental Impact

When choosing the right system for your home or business, it’s also important to consider the environmental impact of electric vs. gas heaters. Gas heaters produce greenhouse gas emissions during combustion, contributing to air pollution and climate change. While modern gas heaters are designed to be more efficient and emit fewer pollutants, they still have an environmental impact. 

On the other hand, an electric heating system has no direct emissions at the point of use, making it a cleaner option for local air quality. However, the environmental impact of electric heaters varies based on the source of electricity in your region. If your electricity comes from fossil fuels, like coal or natural gas, using electric heaters indirectly contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. 

Safety Considerations

When shopping for your heating system, keep in mind that both gas and electric heaters come with their own set of risks. Gas heaters pose potential risks associated with gas leaks, carbon monoxide emissions, and combustion hazards, requiring proper ventilation and regular maintenance. Carbon monoxide detectors are often recommended for added safety. 

While generally safer regarding emissions, electric heat systems can be a fire hazard when placed too close to flammable materials or if they malfunction. It’s essential to follow manufacturer guidelines for safe usage, avoid overloading circuits, and keep flammable objects away from electric heaters. 

Heating Efficiency

Gas heating systems often hold an advantage in quickly warming a space. They produce heat instantly and can provide a high volume of warm air, making them particularly efficient at raising the temperature in a room. 

Electric heaters, while still effective at heating, may take a little longer to reach the desired temperature, especially in larger areas, due to their lower heating capacity. However, some electric heaters, like infrared models, can offer more direct and rapid heating by radiating heat to objects and people, bypassing the need to heat the entire room. 

Energy Efficiency

Gas heaters are more energy efficient, as they can convert a larger amount of the energy source (natural gas or propane) into heat. Efficiency ratings for gas heaters are typically expressed as AFUE (Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency) and can range from 80% to 98% or higher for condensing models. 

Electric heaters, however, tend to have lower energy efficiency ratings due to energy losses during electricity generation and transmission. They are often rated based on their wattage and typically convert all the electricity into heat, but the overall efficiency depends on the source of electricity generation.

Gas heaters often have higher energy efficiency ratings and lower energy consumption when compared to electric heaters, but local factors, such as the cost of natural gas and electricity, can also influence the cost-effectiveness of each option.

Gas vs. Electric Heaters in Carrollton

Choosing the Right Heater for Your Carrollton Home or Business

Selecting the right heater for your Carrollton home or business involves carefully considering several factors. The local climate, including the severity of winters, is important when determining whether a gas or electric heater is better suited to your needs. The size of the space you need to heat, insulation levels, and how frequently you’ll use the heating system also impact your choice. 

When deciding on a new heating system, it’s crucial to seek a professional assessment from Carrollton heating experts at Lex Air Conditioning and Heating. During your consultation, your HVAC technician will thoroughly evaluate your space, considering insulation, heating capacity requirements, energy efficiency goals, and budget constraints. This assessment will not only guide you toward the most appropriate heating system but also ensure that it is installed and maintained correctly for optimal performance, safety, and comfort throughout winter.

How Our Carrollton Heating Installation and Repair Specialists Can Help

Our Carrollton heating installation and repair specialists are dedicated to ensuring your comfort and safety throughout the winter season. Whether you need a new heating system installation or require heater repairs for your current one, our team at Lex Air is here to assist you. We provide both residential and commercial HVAC services, so no matter how big (or small) your problem is, we can handle it.  

Carrollton Heating Installation and Repair Specialists

Trust Lex Air To Help You Find the Right Heating System for Your Home

In the ongoing debate between gas and electric heaters, the choice comes down to many important factors, like installation costs, energy efficiency, versatility, and more. Regardless of your preference, deciding to invest in the right heating system for your Carrollton home or business is significant.

With years of HVAC experience, Lex Air Conditioning and Heating can guide you through this decision-making process. Their professional assessment and recommendations ensure you make an informed choice tailored to your unique needs, budget, and environmental considerations. By trusting Lex Air, you can enjoy a warm and comfortable environment throughout the Carrollton winter, knowing that your heating system is the perfect fit.

To schedule a consultation for your home or business, call the Carrollton heating pros at (972) 217-8955 today.

How Many BTUs Do I Need

How Many BTUs Do I Need?

Determining how many BTUs your heating or cooling system needs is essential for maintaining comfort and efficiency in your Carrollton home or business. At Lex

GFCI Outlet Not Working

GFCI Outlet Not Working

Discovering that your GFCI outlet is not working can be frustrating and inconvenient, especially in crucial areas of your home like the kitchen or bathroom.